Garages are one of the most common—and most overwhelming—spaces I help clients organize. They’re often a catch-all for everything that doesn’t belong in the house: tools, sporting goods, holiday decor, gardening gear, and decades of “just in case” items.
When it’s time to bring order to chaos, one of the key decisions I guide clients through is choosing between open shelving and enclosed cabinetry. Each has its own strengths, and the right choice depends on how the space is used, what’s being stored, and the client’s organizational habits and style.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of each approach, with a professional perspective on what works best for different needs.
Open Shelving: High Visibility, High Function
Why It Works:
- Immediate Access
Open shelving is ideal for clients who need to see and grab items quickly—think avid DIYers, gardeners, or busy families juggling sports schedules. - Budget-Friendly
For clients watching costs, open shelves offer more bang for the buck. Freestanding metal units or wall-mounted brackets can create plenty of storage without breaking the bank. - Modular and Flexible
I often recommend open systems for clients whose needs may shift—seasonally or as families grow. They’re easy to reconfigure, add to, or relocate. - Great for Zones
With a smart labeling system, open shelves can clearly define “zones” (e.g., tools, cleaning supplies, camping gear)—a strategy I always incorporate into garage organizing plans.
Watch Out For:
- Visual Clutter
Unless shelves are carefully curated and maintained, they can quickly look messy. I help clients use bins, baskets, and labels to keep visual order. - Dust Build-Up
Everything is exposed, so I recommend placing less-used or sensitive items in lidded bins, even on open shelves. - Pest Access
Unless your garage is air-tight – and it likely is not – mice, at the very least, may inhabit your space a bit, even if we’re not talking full infestation. They will likely spend some time exploring your open shelves and the items stored there…and leaving their marks! A closed cabinet solution is best for keeping the critters at bay.
Enclosed Cabinetry: A Sleek, Tidy Solution
Why It Works:
- A Polished Look
For clients seeking a clean, “finished” garage—especially those using the space for hobbies, a home gym, or showroom-worthy vehicles—cabinets offer a streamlined appearance. - Out of Sight, Out of Mind (In a Good Way)
Clutter disappears behind doors. For clients who are visually sensitive or prefer minimalism, this can be a huge relief. - Cleaner and Safer Storage
Enclosed cabinets protect items from dust, pests, and kids’ curious hands—perfect for tools, paints, chemicals, or valuables. - Customizable and Professional
As a professional organizer, I often work with cabinet installers to create built-in systems tailored to clients’ specific needs—right down to drawer dividers and integrated workspaces.
Watch Out For:
- Higher Investment
Cabinetry often requires a larger upfront budget. I always discuss long-term value with clients—especially if the goal is resale appeal or multifunctional use. - Accessibility Trade-Offs
Items stored behind closed doors can be forgotten. That’s why I emphasize labeling inside and out and keeping only relevant, categorized items in each unit.
My Go-To Recommendation: Combine Both
In most garage organization projects, I find that a hybrid system offers the best balance:
- Open shelving for everyday items that benefit from visibility and quick access.
- Cabinetry for higher-value, seasonal, or potentially hazardous items.
- Clear bins and labels to bring structure to both systems.
The result is a garage that functions beautifully and looks intentional—a place for everything, less clutter and chaos, but still leaves items findable and accessible when needed. An attractive and practical addition to your living space.
Final Thoughts: Function First, Style Second
Every garage I organize starts with one question: How do you use this space?
Open shelving and enclosed cabinetry are just tools in the toolbox. My job is to listen to your needs, assess your storage habits, and create a customized system that’s easy to maintain—and one that helps you feel calm, not overwhelmed, when you step into your garage.
Need help organizing your garage?
Let’s chat! I offer in-person and virtual consultations to help you reclaim your space and build a system that works for your life. Contact Greater Garages today to get started!